States vs Local Hydraulic Fracturing Bans

In the past few years, hydraulic fracturing/frac bans have become increasingly common in communities opposed to the drilling practice that extracts oil and natural gas from shale rock by injecting sand, water and chemicals into the ground. Such bans focus on either the actual drilling methods or the transportation of waste from the hydraulic fracturing process.

State legislatures are now finding themselves in a fight against local authorities for control of hydraulic fracturing regulations in their own states. While Vermont and New York have already implemented state wide bans on hydraulic fracturing, Texas has banned local bans and Oklahoma is considering banning local bans on the practice as well.

Current hydraulic fracturing ban legislation:

  • Over 470 local measures have passed in towns, cities, and counties.
  • 24 states and Washington D.C. have seen at least one such local measure passed.
  • Oklahoma introduced legislation imposing a ban on local frac bans.

The debate has sparked questions over who has the right to regulate oil and gas activity in the state, state agencies or individual communities. For New York, the state-wide ban followed a court decision that town zoning laws allowed the banning of hydraulic fracturing. In an attempt to achieve a compromise between state and local control, state legislation banning cities and counties from outlawing hydraulic fracturing opens the door for local oil and gas regulations, specifically where it concerns health and safety. Texas House Bill 40, signed into law this week by Governor Greg Abbott, includes a four-part test for determining city drilling regulations while prohibiting hydraulic fracturing bans throughout the state.

Lauren Aragon is a research associate at the National Center for Policy Analysis.

Comments (2)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. CRS says:

    The state of Texas has always had control of their oil and gas industry and hopefully other petroleum rich states will follow their example which seems to be fair to all involved parties. One reason this has become an issues is that towns and cities have expaneded their city limits into rural areas that are privately owned farms and ranches and when the citizens build homes in the expanede areas, the new homeowners want to make the rules on everything from agriculteral and industrial aromas and noise to meet their wishes. This is common when subdivisions are built within sound of long existing shooting ranges.
    Let the buyer beware?

  2. Thanks on your marvelous posting! I definitely enjoyed
    reading it, you may be a great author. I will make certain to bookmark your blog
    and will come back in the future. I want to encourage you to continue your great posts, have a nice morning!

Leave a Reply




If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a Gravatar.