EPA Testing Seems At Odds With Public Statements

“Call us for more information and to see if you qualify!”

What exciting opportunity might this be? How about the chance to be exposed to toxins that the researchers say can cause death.

Indeed, this cheery offer came from a set of flyers printed by the EPA seeking human testing subjects for air pollution experiments.

According to an EPA Inspector General report, during five studies conducted in 2010 and 2011, the EPA conducted experiments on 81 individuals, exposing them to airborne particles known as PM2.5 (basically, soot and dust), diesel exhaust, and ozone. Some test subjects experienced cardiac arrhythmias during the testing, and one woman, with a history of medical problems, was sent to the hospital.

The report describes the five air quality studies, expressing concern that the agency exposed a research subject above the study’s concentration targets and that the EPA’s consent forms did not address all of the risks (including death) surrounding pollutant exposure.

Moreover, only one of the studies’ consent forms “identified the upper range of pollutant exposure for each study subject.” The other four consent forms “did not mention the level of pollutant exposure. Instead, the forms…compared the subject’s level of exposure during the study to the exposure they would receive visiting major cities on smoggy days.”

Why was this info left out? The EPA justified its “smoggy days” description of the study because a study manager “explained that a person breathing 420 [micrograms per cubic meter] for 2 hours would inhale the same concentration as they would breathing 35 [micrograms per cubic meter] (the EPA’s 24-hour standard for PM2.5) for 24 hours in a city such as Los Angeles.”

(The studies actually exposed participants to PM levels of 600 micrograms per cubic meter, and one subject up to 751 micrograms per cubic meter — over 21 times the 24-hour standard!)

“The manager also stated that…the risk is small for those with no overt disease.”

Similarly, the agency failed to mention long-term cancer risks from diesel exhaust because “[a]n EPA manager considered these long-term risks minimal for short-term study exposures.”

And just two of the studies “alerted study subjects to the risk of death for older individuals with cardiovascular disease.”

The IG report provides a table detailing health impacts derived from EPA regulations and assessments from short-term exposure to particulate matter and diesel exhaust. For PM2.5, “mortality” is listed as a risk of short-term exposure.chart

What else has the EPA told us about PM2.5?

  • “If we could reduce particulate matter to levels that are healthy, we would have an identical impact to finding a cure for cancer.” — EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson, testimony in front of the Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations, House Committee on Energy and Commerce, September 22, 2011.
  • “Particulate matter causes premature deaths. It doesn’t make you sick. It is directly causal to dying sooner than you should.” — EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson, testimony in front of the Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations, House Committee on Energy and Commerce, September 22, 2011.
  • “Overall, there is strong epidemiological evidence linking… short-term (hours, days) exposures to PM2.5 with cardiovascular and respiratory mortality and morbidity.” — EPA report on Air Quality Criteria for Particulate Matter, Volume II, October 2004.
  • “Short-term exposures to particles (hours or days) can aggravate lung disease, causing asthma attacks and acute bronchitis, and may also increase susceptibility to respiratory infections. In people with heart disease, short-term exposures have been linked to heart attacks and arrhythmias.” — EPA brochure on Particle Pollution and Your Health.
  • “The new studies support previous conclusions that short-term exposure to fine PM is associated with both mortality and morbidity.” — EPA report on Provisional Assessment of Recent Studies on Health Effects of Particulate Matter Exposure, July 2006.
  • “The best scientific evidence, confirmed by independent, Congressionally-mandated expert panels, is that there is no threshold level of fine particle pollution below which health risk reductions are not achieved by reduced exposure.” — Letter from Gina McCarthy, Asst. Administrator of the EPA, to Rep. Fred Upton, February 3, 2012.

In these reports and statements, exposure to PM 2.5 is dangerous (indeed, there is apparently no level of pollution at which health risks cease!). But the EPA’s human testing? Apparently not so dangerous.

The IG report summed up the agency’s missing warnings about the link between PM exposure and health effects this way: “This lack of warning about PM…is also different from its public message about PM.”

When an agency hails the reduction of particulate matter as the public health equivalent of curing cancer — and regulates on that basis — it loses credibility when it exposes humans to high levels of the pollutants and deems such exposure safe.

So, has the EPA exaggerated the effects of these particles in order to justify heavy-handed regulation? Or is the agency knowingly conducting dangerous experiments on human subjects?

Whichever it is, neither answer is comforting.

Comments (11)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Jeremy says:

    I wholeheartedly agree. What I think has happened here is energy policy opportunism. Natural gas transitions and that industry has been sucking in environmental and health lobbies to exaggerate particulate matter (a mix of possibly toxic, possibly non-toxic – unquantifiable by toxicology, non-replicable by scientific method, and only suggested toxic by particle size = convenience by lobbied persuasion campaigns – using and abusing statistical analysis). What about the GHGs and poisons from the natural gas industry? Well wash your mouth out, we must destroy coal and domestic wood fuel (or use only control technologies that use natural gas or excessive use of electricity). All other sustainable forms are held at ransom in the lab, waiting for those researchers and technicians to pay off the policy makers, already being comfortably paid off by the natural gas expansionists. The mission was to phase in natural gas, and phase out everything else – and to persuade public consent that non-toxic particles were the greater risk. The (especially cheap and easy)technology that has been successful at stopping visible smoke from wood stoves for example, is held back until the fossil fuel clean energy fakers pays off enough people in authority to fabricate justifications to stop the sale of them altogether.

  2. ” He had been admitted to the ER due to a heart attack. You finally screw up your courage – even if the news is bad, it’s best to know the truth, you tell yourself – and then do the test. HCG diet materials stress the importance of sticking to this diet.

    Feel free to visit my web page; hcg injections for weight loss how much

  3. Trent says:

    I do agree with all the ideas you have offered on your post.
    They’re very convincing and will definitely work. Still, the
    posts are too short for starters. May just you please
    extend them a little from subsequent time? Thank you for
    the post.

    Feel free to visit my web-site … homepage [Trent]

  4. Techniques and trends like branding, managed care contracts, practice ownership,
    and sales have not been as affective (Beckman).
    Long haul targets are the final consequence of all these deliberations – more prominent deceivability, profit
    and gainfulness. SEO (search engine optimization) is a term
    that is freely bandied about by people who like to make the art of internet marketing seem mysterious.

    Look at my site: social media marketing que es

  5. Yet he chose to ask me so many questions
    about how and why I do things, because he could see the profound insight I had built up due to going my own way with my own research and testing over the past 7
    years. Leave your windows open a few hours a day and then you get to clean the black soot off of the floors.
    If you are getting ready to go deep-sea fishing, there are a
    few things you might want to know about sea fishing bait.

    my site: duck box for sale

  6. Graciela says:

    Howdy! This is kind of off topic but I need some advice
    from an established blog. Is it hard to set up your
    own blog? I’m not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty quick.
    I’m thinking about setting up my own but I’m not sure
    where to begin. Do you have any tips or suggestions? Cheers

    Feel free to surf to my weblog … garcinia total in stores,

  7. This bikini is available online or in store at Macy’s. You know
    very well that Evening dresses UK are formal outfits and
    they are available in an array of fabrics like satin, georgette,
    chiffon, velvet and soft material like that. What kind of dresses
    look good for both creating an elegant appearance and
    for still looking right as club wear.

    Look into my homepage; unique boutique dress store

  8. Fruits are great and I would never discourage my patients from eating fruit, but if your objective
    is to lose weight then they have to be eliminated, as they prevent Ketosis.
    The target for the five hundred calories is high-protein foods.
    You can consult your neighbors and family members for references.

    my homepage; hcg weight loss jacksonville

  9. In time the daughter grows old, but within her there is always a deep longing
    for her father. While Naphtha is not commonly discussed, it is a great alternative to butane
    and propane. The important to making helpful telemarketing scripts is beginning with brief introduction of oneself and the company you are representing.
    You can find companies offering packing services and this means that you have
    less to worry about when moving. Similar to time-limited recesses, these applications are generally designed for unpaid
    caretakers that are working together with services over and above properties.
    The 24 buttons can be customized to meet the needs of different users.
    Ideally, modern design prefers L-shaped workstations to save space while encouraging interaction among office employees.
    They will used simply by several sportsmen, celebrities, artists and also superstars for instance –
    Supra Skytopwill be duplicated, of his concerts and also roller
    skates celebrations. Simply said, a one way truck is a rental method that allows you to rent a truck
    in a given state and return it at the destination state to a
    branch of the same company in that area. There are more safety precautions you can include in your warehouse storage shelving such as
    shims, wall ties, footplates, extra struts, pallet supports and wire decking, and more.

    Here is my webpage: movers and shakers dcnepal

  10. One of the color that brought glimmering style was Black.

    Not only is Junior sized clothing not cut for a woman’s figure, it also shows more skin that we would like.

    It won’t be long before you can move up into the world and have these
    same people, schools and agencies calling you to set up glamour photography or fashion photography sessions to
    meet their needs and purposes.

    My blog bandage Dress haul master

  11. Anyone who is interested in this plan can find numerous recipes
    and resources on the Internet. Physically, because it wrecks havoc to your body systems that have to attune different metabolic,
    circulatory and gastrointestinal processes in between relatively short periods of time.
    Bones and nails are also strengthened, which is an important factor that effects more than your appearance.

    My web page … personal training mt eliza

Leave a Reply

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a Gravatar.